Monday, June 3, 2013

Creating Cyber-Related Risks - We are getting good at it!



There is not a day that goes by that there is not some discussion of Cyber or computer risks. For the largest part, it seems that the discussion is focused on the risk of information being hacked from government and government contractor systems. For example:

However, risks are more than hacking. There are other risks in the use of computers that we are adding on a day-to-day basis. Examples include:
  • Personal information shared both overtly and unknowingly on Social Networking sites such as Twitter, Facebook, Google+, etc.
  • Use of feature-rich business productivity services such as Google Apps for business.
  • Vehicle "telematics" systems such as OnStar.
  • Web accessible home security and energy management systems.
  • The nascent start of autonomous vehicles for consumers
Each of these risks alone are interesting, but taken together they form a comprehensive set of vulnerabilities that means an attack can come from just about anywhere in the world and strike at just about any time.

Let’s take them in order from above:

People are putting a tremendous amount of information into services such as Facebook, LinkedIn, Google+, etc. Much of this is personal information such as birthdays, home locations (current and past), education, contact information, presence and location information. These systems are now starting to include so call “two-factor” authentication to prevent unauthorized access to a person’s account - which should be a positive step in security. So, what are the risks:
  • This does absolutely nothing to stop the use of the information the user has already and continues to place in the system.
  • It also does not stop criminals who target and “social engineer” the user into “friending”, exposing the personal information to essentially the world.
  • I’m apparently on vacation or at a restaurant or bar, so come rob my house.
  • I placed enough information for the criminal to social engineer their way into other systems the victim may use. It may even be enough information to do a complete “Identity Theft” operation.


Business are moving in drive to the “Cloud”. In fact, I am writing this using Google Docs on my corporate Google Apps for Business account. The environment holds our email, calendars, selected documents, and messaging environment. Again, two-factor authentication can be used to secure access to the system, for a user or especially those that are administrators. Google constantly works to make their service more useful, attractive, and “sticky” to their customers. For example, the Google Now service, fully integrated into our employee’s smartphones (for those that use Android), searches their calendars, knows where they are, tells them when they should leave where they are to get to their next appointment, check them in for an upcoming airplane flight, as well as information based other items of interest to the employee. There are several risks again:

  • Unsurprisingly, for a user that is exploiting all the features of Google Apps, a compromised account provides a treasure trove of business and personal information, as well as essentially near-real time information of their location
  • Potential for access, on demand, by government investigators, such as the ominous (in my opinion) demands on Google to provide warrant-less access to customer accounts (see, Judge Tells Google To Five the FBI Customer Data)
  • In fact, just one account may not be compromised as the controls put into place by the Cloud service providers are apparently not all they need to be (see, BT Moves From Cloud Provider Based on Hacking Vulnerabilities)

The evolution of remote capabilities being embedded in the common car is transforming the relationship between car owner, their car, and the car manufacturer. No longer is the car just a sale to the customer with the potential of after sale service, the sale is now one that contains a growing list of services. Enabled by virtually continuous access to 3G and soon 4G wireless, there are services that:
  • Provide vehicle service information back to the manufacturer
  • Provides GPS and Cell Tower information to a services provider for navigation and traffic information
  • Enables a car that is reported stolen to be disabled
  • Enables an owner via a smartphone or tablet to open the car’s doors, start the car, and other functions
The risks here are profound. Insider threats, backdoors in the service provider’s systems, vulnerabilities in smartphone security, means that virtually any car can be stolen, tracked, or disabled remotely. In addition, as with the use of Cloud-based business services, information on a car’s travels may be demanded from the service provider by the government. Combined with your Cloud business information, someone is always able to track where you have been, where you are, and where you are going.

The more recent “oh my goodness” is the use of Internet-based home management systems. These systems, which are now being packaged by Cable and Telecom companies, as well as the traditional home security services, not only control the whether a home’s alarm system is active or turned-off, but also the heating and cooling system, cameras, and some can even open door locks. With the convenience of a mobile App, with a few swipes or presses you are in control. Of course, so it anyone that is able to take control of your smartphone, your security account, and certainly staff at the service providers operation centers (which makes me think of where these may be located). Again, like other well publicized cases, attacks on service providers have yielded access to thousands of user accounts.

A couple of scenarios:
  • You may think it is cool that you can make sure the lights are on in your house and the air conditioning is turned back on to prepare for your arrival from a long vacation, but what you may find is that the doors of the house are open and your valuables gone
  • You may think that you have the privacy of your own home, but what you really have is the government, a robber, a spy on your personal or business life, doing a bit of snooping without your knowledge.
Finally, I end on talking about autonomous cars. Lately, we have been entertained in the news on how far this technology has gone. Just a decade ago, these were lumbering vehicles moving only a few miles-an-hour on a course safely tucked away from the potential to harm anything or anyone. Now, these are moving through cities and highways navigating around work zones and what would appear to be difficult driving situations. In light of the progress, the Federal Government wants States to be a bit apprehensive (see, Caution Urged in Allowing Autonomous Cars).

In this case, it probably does not take a Cyber attack to gum-up the works. With a little ingenuity, paint, signs, and fake barriers, I wonder how hard it would be to fake the car into deciding that the road is under construction and the detour leads directly through my house.  Think of the damage that a "terrorist" could do on the D.C. Capitol Beltway (all without a firearm, fertilizer, or other items normally associated with an "act of terror").

All combined, we are creating a Cyber and Computer risk environment that is all around us. It is not clear how to even begin to deal with the combination business risk, U.S. Constitutional issues, business risk, personal property risks, national security risks that may become a security whack-a-mole - especially if being directed by a foreign (or domestic) adversary for money or power.

Thursday, January 3, 2013

Bandwidth use increases, revenue not so much...

I have been tracking my home’s bandwidth usage for over the past two years. My original concerns were twofold. First, usage seems to relentlessly increase, and second, many Internet Services Providers (ISPs) had a bandwidth cap of around 50 GBytes. per month.

I estimated that the “Bandwidth Bomb” for me would go off sometime in 2013 and it did, with some troughs, but I clearly would have exceeded my ISP’s acceptable use policy of no more than 250 GBytes transferred per month. Comcast’s Website assured me that the cap was generous enough and that only an exceedingly small percentage of users would ever have to worry about the Comcast bandwidth police.

As an amazing coincidence, just as I predicted I would exceed the cap, Comcast changed its policy and “Note:enforcement of the 250GB data consumption threshold is currently suspended”. So, at least for the time being, I can enjoy 2013 without a home bandwidth worry in the world.
So what about the first issue above, how did my home’s traffic change over the past couple of years? First let’s see what changes happened at the Kaplow home. We are now the owners of three iPhones and an Android Pad. When in the home, these connect to my home WiFi network. My own phone, also an Android-based phone stays happily on Verizon’s wireless LTE network as I have still have a grandfathered unlimited bandwidth plan.

The Xbox also go smarter with an upgrade that includes Kinect. The youngest son discovered its use not only as an game console and Netflix player, but also as a party-line (if you know what that is) for a couple of hours every day playing cooperative games (of course after all his homework is done and done well). There were no significant changes to the laptop inventory.

Let’s look at the bandwidth trends at my house. The first set of bars represent the four month average from September through December in each year. The data shows a 77% increase from 2010 and an additional 83% into 2012. So from 2010 to 2012 the last third of the year’s usage increased 325%!


Looking at the total year 2011 and 2012, this represents an average that went from 111 to 182 Gbytes per month or a 65% increase. If this trend continues, to continue the same business margins, my ISP has to wring costs from their infrastructure or raise prices. Alternatively, they could find a way to make money on other services. Currently, some of the infrastructure is covered via the bundle of TV and voice services. With streaming content from providers other than the cable company itself, will we see a trend that mimicked that the traditional telephone company saw people turning off their telephone for “naked” DSL Internet service, with people turning off or significantly reducing their TV content?

There are also additional pressures on cable (or even services provided by the traditional local phone service provider) revenues:
  • Verizon is offering home phone service delivered over their mobile network. This takes away one of the “bundle” revenue elements. 
  • Satellite services. This takes away the broadcast channel elements, putting even more pressure on access on-demand material over the Internet.
  • Wireless providers in general. With the continued build-out of 4G LTE services, there will likely be a growing number people that just use a wireless provider for their home service. Much of this is just a pricing plan away (with of course, within the limits of the available spectrum, etc.).


So, the potential trend of reduced services revenue combined with increased Internet use means that it is likely that Internet service costs will increase if only to enable cable and other wire provider companies to maintain their revenue - with an unknown hit to margins. On the other hand, they may have to hold the line on pricing, if only to keep their customer base in the face of competition.